User Poll
What caused the extinction of large North American mammals about 40,000 years ago?
What caused the extinction of large North American mammals about 40,000 years ago?
-
ToggleThey were hunted to extinction by the Native Americans.
unisci.com (1 statement)
View source report for unisci.com
Wikipedia (1 statement)
View source report for Wikipedia
Discovery Channel (2 statements)
View source report for Discovery Channel
Paul S. Martin (paleontologist) (3 statements)
Show all statements from this source. | View source report for Paul S. Martin (paleontologist)
Gary Haynes (Univ. of Nevada Reno) (1 statement)
View source report for Gary Haynes (Univ. of Nevada Reno)
actionbioscience.org (4 statements)
Show all statements from this source. | View source report for actionbioscience.org
everything2.com (1 statement)
View source report for everything2.com
About.com (1 statement)
View source report for About.com
cpluhna.nau.edu (1 statement)
View source report for cpluhna.nau.edu
highbeam.com (1 statement)
View source report for highbeam.com
eurekalert.org (1 statement)
View source report for eurekalert.org
slideshare.net (1 statement)
View source report for slideshare.net
goliath.ecnext.com (1 statement)
View source report for goliath.ecnext.com
outriderbooks.com (1 statement)
View source report for outriderbooks.com
musmusmreading.blogspot.com (1 statement)
View source report for musmusmreading.blogspot.com
-
ToggleDisease.
New York Times (2 statements)
View source report for New York Times
Wikipedia (1 statement)
View source report for Wikipedia
everything2.com (1 statement)
View source report for everything2.com
Preston A. Marx (virologist) (1 statement)
View source report for Preston A. Marx (virologist)
Ross D.E. MacPhee (American Museum of Natu... (3 statements)
Show all statements from this source. | View source report for Ross D.E. MacPhee (American Museum of Natural History)
cpluhna.nau.edu (2 statements)
Show all statements from this source. | View source report for cpluhna.nau.edu
mcdaniel.edu (1 statement)
View source report for mcdaniel.edu
musmusmreading.blogspot.com (1 statement)
View source report for musmusmreading.blogspot.com
-
ToggleClimate change.
Wikipedia (1 statement)
View source report for Wikipedia
Discovery Channel (1 statement)
View source report for Discovery Channel
everything2.com (1 statement)
View source report for everything2.com
About.com (1 statement)
View source report for About.com
Russell W. Graham (Denver Museum of Natura... (1 statement)
View source report for Russell W. Graham (Denver Museum of Natural History)
cpluhna.nau.edu (3 statements)
Show all statements from this source. | View source report for cpluhna.nau.edu
Donald Grayson (Univ. of Washington) (2 statements)
Show all statements from this source. | View source report for Donald Grayson (Univ. of Washington)
-
A meteor impact.
Wikipedia (1 statement)
View source report for Wikipedia
James Kennett (Univ. of California Santa B... (1 statement)
View source report for James Kennett (Univ. of California Santa Barbara)
-
A supernova blasted them with gamma radiation.
Independent (UK newspaper) (1 statement)
View source report for Independent (UK newspaper)
They were hunted to extinction by the Native Americans.
unisci.com
Did Humans Cause Extinctions? Archaeologist Says No
The overkill hypothesis was proposed by retired University of Arizona ecologist Paul Martin in 1967 and its basic arguments haven't changed since.
Wikipedia
Pleistocene megafauna - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Four theories have been given for these extinctions: hunting by the spreading humans, climatic change, spreading disease, and an impact from an asteroid or comet.
Discovery Channel
Climate Not Culprit of Megafauna Extinction : Discovery News
The appetites and activities of humans streaming into the continent across a land bridge from Asia provide another possible culprit.
Climate Not Culprit of Megafauna Extinction : Discovery News
As a result, it's looking more and more like humans played a major role.
Paul S. Martin (paleontologist)
Blame North America Megafauna Extinction On Climate Change, Not Human Ancestors
The overkill hypothesis was proposed by retired University of Arizona ecologist Paul Martin in 1967 and its basic arguments haven't changed since.
What Became of the Megafauna? » American Scientist
In Twilight of the Mammoths: Ice Age Extinctions and the Rewilding of America, Paul S. Martin reviews the end-Pleistocene extinction, arguing that overkill is the more likely explanation.
the mass extinction of the North American megafauna in the late Pleistocene@Everything2.com
Martin's theory is that humans were directly responsible for the mass extinction in the Late Pleistocene due to over hunting.
Gary Haynes (Univ. of Nevada Reno)
NOVA | End of the Big Beasts
Archeologist Gary Haynes, University of Nevada Reno, and others think that the continent's first human hunters, fresh from Siberia, killed the megafauna off as they colonized the newly discovered land.
actionbioscience.org
Mammoths: Resurrecting Extinct Megafauna (ActionBioscience)
A very different perspective, at least from the view of a North American, is shown by the following analogy: It can be demonstrated that humans had a hand in the North American extinction of the mammoths (and possibly other Pleistocene megafauna).
Mammoths: Resurrecting Extinct Megafauna (ActionBioscience)
There is compelling evidence that humans had a role in mammoth extinction, at least in North America.
Rewilding Megafauna: Lions and Camels in North America? (ActionBioscience)
The majority view in mainstream science now is that humans were the main cause of the extinction of these large animals, called megafauna.
Mammoths: Resurrecting Extinct Megafauna (ActionBioscience)
There is compelling evidence that humans had a role in mammoth extinction, at least in North America.
everything2.com
the mass extinction of the North American megafauna in the late Pleistocene@Everything2.com
Conclusion The mostly likely cause of the mass extinctions in North America at the end of the Pleistocene is a combination of both environmental cause and overkill.
About.com
Megafauna Extinctions - What were the Megafauna Extinctions
The mass extinctions were not synchronous nor universal, and the reasons proffered for them include (but are not limited to) climate change and human intervention.
cpluhna.nau.edu
Pleistocene Megafauna Extinctions on the Colorado Plateau
An opposing camp, pointing out that the extinctions closely followed the animals' first contact with modern humans, holds that the megafauna were essentially hunted to extinction.
highbeam.com
Spores tell tale of megafauna's disappearance: dung fungus finds ...
As a result, it's looking more and more like humans played a major role.
eurekalert.org
Blame North America megafauna extinction on climate change, not ...
The overkill hypothesis was proposed by retired University of Arizona ecologist Paul Martin in 1967 and its basic arguments haven't changed since.
trussel.com
Megafauna extinction mystery
One long-popular theory holds that the Clovis people, Stone Age immigrants from Asia who appeared in North America about 11,000 years ago, swept across the continent and hunted most of its large mammals to extinction.
slideshare.net
Lessons2and3thelittleiceage climate and change Edexcel Geography ...
ARCHEOLOGIST GARY HAYNES, UNIVERSITY OF NEVADA RENO, AND OTHERS THINK THAT THE CONTINENT'S FIRST HUMAN HUNTERS, FRESH FROM SIBERIA, KILLED THE MEGAFAUNA OFF AS THEY COLONIZED THE NEWLY DISCOVERED LAND.
goliath.ecnext.com
Spores tell tale of megafauna's disappearance: dung fungus finds ...
As a result, it's looking more and more like humans played a major role.
outriderbooks.com
woolly mammoth extinction out there science report at outrider
The overkill hypothesis was proposed by retired University of Arizona ecologist Paul Martin in 1967 and its basic arguments haven't changed since.
musmusmreading.blogspot.com
musmusmreading.blogspot.com
Archeologist Gary Haynes, University of Nevada Reno, and others think that the continent's first human hunters, fresh from Siberia, killed the megafauna off as they colonized the newly discovered land.
Disease.
New York Times
Disease Is New Suspect in Ancient Extinctions
It is simply too much to believe that ''a few thousand Indian men with pointed sticks could run around a continent and bring to extinction 135 species in maybe 400 years,'' said Dr. Ross D. E. MacPhee, a mammalogist at the American Museum of Natural History in New York, who advances the new disease hypothesis.
Disease Is New Suspect in Ancient Extinctions
Scientists who find neither the climatic nor the blitzkrieg theory convincing argue that rampant disease was the main villain.
Wikipedia
Pleistocene megafauna - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Four theories have been given for these extinctions: hunting by the spreading humans, climatic change, spreading disease, and an impact from an asteroid or comet.
everything2.com
the mass extinction of the North American megafauna in the late Pleistocene@Everything2.com
Hyperdisease Theory The most recent development in the search for a cause has been that of the hyperdisease theory.
Preston A. Marx (virologist)
Pleistocene Megafauna Extinctions on the Colorado Plateau
The disease hypothesis, worked out by Dr. MacPhee and Dr. Preston A. Marx, a virologist at the Aaron Diamond AIDS Research Center in New York, holds that the animals were infected by lethal pathogens unknown to their immune systems.
Ross D.E. MacPhee (American Museum of Natural History)
NOVA | End of the Big Beasts
Mammalogist Ross MacPhee of the American Museum of Natural History has advanced the idea, with virologist Preston Marx, that a virulent "hyperdisease" brought by the first Americans might have raced through species with no natural immunity, bringing about their demise.
Megafauna extinction mystery
Instead, MacPhee is betting that a virus or other microbe new to the Americas arrived with human settlers and killed off many mammal species that had no natural resistance.
Pleistocene Megafauna Extinctions on the Colorado Plateau
It is simply too much to believe that "a few thousand Indian men with pointed sticks could run around a continent and bring to extinction 135 species in maybe 400 years," said Dr. Ross D.E. MacPhee, a mammalogist at the American Museum of Natural History in New York, who advances the new disease hypothesis.
cpluhna.nau.edu
Pleistocene Megafauna Extinctions on the Colorado Plateau
Scientists who find neither the climatic nor the blitzkrieg theory convincing argue that rampant disease was the main villain.
Pleistocene Megafauna Extinctions on the Colorado Plateau
Scientists who find neither the climatic nor the blitzkrieg theory convincing argue that rampant disease was the main villain.
trussel.com
Megafauna extinction mystery
Another scenario casts human immigrants (or perhaps animals or insects they brought with them) as unwitting deliverers of a killer virus that devastated the continent's wildlife.
mcdaniel.edu
The Grasslands of the US - McDaniel College
Scientists who find neither the climatic nor the blitzkrieg theory convincing argue that rampant disease was the main villain.
musmusmreading.blogspot.com
musmusmreading.blogspot.com
Mammalogist Ross MacPhee of the American Museum of Natural History has advanced the idea, with virologist Preston Marx, that a virulent "hyperdisease" brought by the first Americans might have raced through species with no natural immunity, bringing about their demise.
Climate change.
Wikipedia
Pleistocene megafauna - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Four theories have been given for these extinctions: hunting by the spreading humans, climatic change, spreading disease, and an impact from an asteroid or comet.
Discovery Channel
Climate Not Culprit of Megafauna Extinction : Discovery News
Researchers have long debated what triggered the extinctions that struck North American megafauna between 14,000 and 11,000 years ago (SN: 12/4/99, p. 360), and one of the prime candidates has been habitat change caused by a warming climate.
everything2.com
the mass extinction of the North American megafauna in the late Pleistocene@Everything2.com
Environmental Cause Theory The first suspect in the search was the changing environmental conditions occurring in North America, and around the world, about 11,000 years ago.
About.com
Megafauna Extinctions - What were the Megafauna Extinctions
The mass extinctions were not synchronous nor universal, and the reasons proffered for them include (but are not limited to) climate change and human intervention.
Russell W. Graham (Denver Museum of Natural History)
Pleistocene Megafauna Extinctions on the Colorado Plateau
In this hypothesis, advocated by Dr. Russell W. Graham of the Denver Museum of Natural History among others, North America in the earlier Pleistocene was dotted shore to shore by different habitats, each favorable to particular species.
cpluhna.nau.edu
Pleistocene Megafauna Extinctions on the Colorado Plateau
Those who subscribe to the climate-change theory of the extinctions argue that the driving force behind them was the destruction of habitat brought about by oscillating periods of warmth and cold during the Pleistocene era, the era of on-and-off glaciation that began about a million years ago.
Pleistocene Megafauna Extinctions on the Colorado Plateau
One camp in the debate contends that a rapidly changing climate at the end of the last ice age did in the Pleistocene megafauna, as they are called, by transforming their habitat.
Pleistocene Megafauna Extinctions on the Colorado Plateau
Those who subscribe to the climate-change theory of the extinctions argue that the driving force behind them was the destruction of habitat brought about by oscillating periods of warmth and cold during the Pleistocene era, the era of on-and-off glaciation that began about a million years ago.
Donald Grayson (Univ. of Washington)
Blame North America Megafauna Extinction On Climate Change, Not Human Ancestors
Grayson points to climate shifts, during the late Pleistocene epoch, which ended about 10,000 years ago, and subsequent changes in weather and plants as the likely culprits in the demise of North America's megafauna.
NOVA | End of the Big Beasts
Donald Grayson, an archeologist at the University of Washington, Seattle, along with colleague David Meltzer of Southern Methodist University, believes that climate changes at the end of the Pleistocene epoch triggered the collapse.
trussel.com
Megafauna extinction mystery
According to one view, rapid climate shifts at the end of the Ice Age altered the pattern of North American vegetation, shrinking the habitats of the big mammals until they became extinct.
A meteor impact.
Wikipedia
Pleistocene megafauna - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Four theories have been given for these extinctions: hunting by the spreading humans, climatic change, spreading disease, and an impact from an asteroid or comet.
James Kennett (Univ. of California Santa Barbara)
NOVA | End of the Big Beasts
And, in the newest hypothesis advanced, geologist James Kennett, U.C. Santa Barbara, and colleagues propose that a comet impact or airburst over North America did it.
A supernova blasted them with gamma radiation.
Independent (UK newspaper)
The end of the world as we know it - Science, News - The Independent
The demise of large North American mammals 41, 000 years ago has been linked to a supernova, and several other mini-extinctions may be tied to the cataclysm of stellar death.