Innocent

American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU)

Shouting From the Rooftops » Blog of Rights: Official Blog of the ...

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

Gerald Hurst (arson analyst)

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

Hurst concluded that there was no evidence of arson, and that a man who had already lost his three children and spent twelve years in jail was about to be executed based on “junk science

New Yorker (magazine)

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

Did Texas execute an innocent man?

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

Atlantic (magazine)

Did Texas Execute An Innocent Man? - The Daily Dish - The Atlantic

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

examiner.com

Is Texas governor Rick Perry attempting a cover-up? - Cleveland ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

innocenceproject.org

The Innocence Project - Cameron Todd Willingham: Wrongfully Convicted and Executed in Texas

Since 2004, further evidence in the case has led to the inescapable conclusion that Willingham did not set the fire for which he was executed.

blogs.chicagotribune.com

Change of Subject: GOP debate transcripts

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”"

Huffington Post

Cameron Todd Willingham: Did Texas Execute An Innocent Man?

After reading Grann's report, fair-minded people will know beyond a reasonable doubt that an innocent person was executed

Cameron Todd Willingham: Did Texas Execute An Innocent Man?

Cameron Todd Willingham: Did Texas Execute An Innocent Man?

Barry Scheck: Innocent, but Executed - Breaking News and Opinion ...

After reading Grann's report, fair-minded people will know beyond a reasonable doubt that an innocent person was executed

themoderatevoice.com

The Executioner's Tale | The Moderate Voice

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

capitalpunishmentbook.com

WAS CAMERON TODD WILLINGHAM INNOCENT?

But the State of Texas, like most others, would prefer to execute an innocent man than to admit it had wrongfully convicted him.

WAS CAMERON TODD WILLINGHAM INNOCENT?

The Stare of Texas—and in particular Gov. Rick Perry—had ample credible evidence with the Hurst report to know there was a reasonable probability that Willingham did not intentionally set the fire that killed his three children

dailykos.com

Rick Perry Continues Cover Up; Calls Executed Innocent Man "a ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Todd Willingham's Defense Lawyer Embarrasses Texas Justice System ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Todd Willingham's Defense Lawyer Embarrasses Texas Justice System ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Rick Perry Continues Cover Up; Calls Executed Innocent Man "a ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Rick Perry Continues Cover Up; Calls Executed Innocent Man "a ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Is Rick Perry Hiding Smoking Gun in Todd Willingham Case?

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Todd Willingham's Defense Lawyer Embarrasses Texas Justice System ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Daily Kos: Political murder 101 - the lethal injection of innocents

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the "execution of a legally and factually innocent person."

Daily Kos: Rick Perry Hides His Own Culpability

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

talkleft.com

Cameron Todd Willingham and How To Prevent Another Wrongful ...

After reading Grann's report, fair-minded people will know beyond a reasonable doubt that an innocent person was executed.

democraticunderground.com

Ex-Texas death row inmate freed; AG drops charges - Democratic ...

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the execution of a legally and factually innocent person.

wnd.com

Innocence Inquiry Commission isunique to North Carolina ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Post-Koppel, late-night news program has multiple anchors, barely ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Innocence Inquiry Commission isunique to North Carolina ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Post-Koppel, late-night news program has multiple anchors, barely ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Texas ruling ends inquiry in death penalty case - Worldnews.com

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Popular comics author spins a woodland fable - Worldnews.com

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Innocence Inquiry Commission isunique to North Carolina ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Post-Koppel, late-night news program has multiple anchors, barely ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Editorial: Forensic panel should be aggressive, despite AG opinion ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Perry 'squashed' Texas execution probe, ex-official says ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Post-Koppel, late-night news program has multiple anchors, barely ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Texas attorney general's ruling ends commission's inquiry into ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Texas ruling ends inquiry in death penalty case - Worldnews.com

Texas executed an innocent person.

Texas ruling ends inquiry in death penalty case - Worldnews.com

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Editorial: Forensic panel should be aggressive, despite AG opinion ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Innocence Inquiry Commission isunique to North Carolina ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Texas ruling ends inquiry in death penalty case - Worldnews.com

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

patheos.com

Pro-life voters, take note | The Deacon's Bench

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

“Faithful Citizenship”? What's that? | The Deacon's Bench

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

innocentsexecuted.com

Todd Willingham | Innocents Executed

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Todd Willingham | Innocents Executed

Texas executed an innocent person.

Todd Willingham | Innocents Executed

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Todd Willingham | Innocents Executed

The proven execution of an innocent person should mean the end of the death penalty in the United States.

Todd Willingham | Innocents Executed

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

SodaHead.com

Should Governor Rick Perry Attend GOP Debate or Wildfires in ...

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the "execution of a legally and factually innocent person."

stopexecutions.blogspot.com

Texas Moratorium Network: Todd Willingham's Defense Lawyer ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Texas Moratorium Network: Host a Viewing Party and Watch World ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Texas Moratorium Network: Todd Willingham's Defense Lawyer ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Texas Moratorium Network: Todd Willingham's Defense Lawyer ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

wn.com

Nightline The Wrongful Execution Of Cameron Todd Willingham

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Todd Willingham Case Discussed At Texas Forensic Science ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Execution Part 2 Of 2 - World News

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Nightline The Wrongful Execution Of Cameron Todd Willingham

Texas executed an innocent person.

Rip Frances Newton Innocent Woman Executed By Texas

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Nightline The Wrongful Execution Of Cameron Todd Willingham

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Todd Willingham Case Discussed At Texas Forensic Science ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Execution Part 2 Of 2 - World News

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Nightline The Wrongful Execution Of Cameron Todd Willingham

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Rip Frances Newton Innocent Woman Executed By Texas

Texas executed an innocent person.

Rip Frances Newton Innocent Woman Executed By Texas

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Rip Frances Newton Innocent Woman Executed By Texas

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

camerontoddwillingham.com

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed

Cameron Todd Willingham - Innocent and Executed

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Full Video ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Uncategorized

Texas executed an innocent person.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Rick Perry ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Rick Perry ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Full Video ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Todd ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Uncategorized

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Todd ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » “Shout it from ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Todd ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Uncategorized

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Rick Perry ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed

Texas executed an innocent person.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Watch the ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Full Video ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Full Video ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » Todd ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed

The proven execution of an innocent person should mean the end of the death penalty in the United States.

scam.com

Cowboy Rick Executed An Innocent Man-Covered It Up

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the execution of a legally and factually innocent person."

digbysblog.blogspot.com

the blogs - Hullabaloo

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

wrongful-convictions.blogspot.com

wrongful-convictions: October 2009

Texas executed an innocent person.

wrongful-convictions: October 2009

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

wrongful-convictions: October 2009

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

lethal-injection-florida.blogspot.com

Lethal Injection: October 2009

Texas executed an innocent person.

Lethal Injection: Todd Willingham's Defense Lawyer Embarrasses ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Lethal Injection: October 2009

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Lethal Injection: Todd Willingham's Defense Lawyer Embarrasses ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Lethal Injection: Todd Willingham's Defense Lawyer Embarrasses ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Lethal Injection: October 2009

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Cameron Todd Willingham (convicted murderer)

Cameron Todd Willingham « Prison Photography

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Execution of Todd Willingham - Crimeshots© True Crime Forums

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Lethal Injection: Trial by Fire

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

If the pro-life movement respect life, would they support capital ...

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Trial by Fire « Gyrovague's Raves

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Mississippi Innocence Project » Blog Archive » The science of arson ...

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

New Yorker Story On Innocent Killed By Death Penalty: "Trial By ...

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

AN INNOCENT MAN HAS BEEN EXECUTED! - Steve Hodel

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Mississippi Innocence Project » 2010 » October

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Cameron Todd Willingham – Innocent and Executed » New Yorker ...

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Steve Hodel: August 2009 Archives

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Steve Hodel: Steve Hodel: August 2009 Archives

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Does rick perry care about innocence or guilt - Why did Rick Perry ...

He insisted upon his innocence in the deaths of his children and refused an offer to plead guilty in return for a life sentence.

Stacy Willingham (wife of Cameron Willingham)

A Gentleman's view. | Rick Perry's Texas Death Row!

Therefore, I believe that there is no way he could have possibly committed this crime.”

Execution of Todd Willingham - Crimeshots© True Crime Forums

Therefore, I believe that there is no way he could have possibly committed this crime.

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

“I don’t think he did it,” she said, crying.

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

Therefore, I believe that there is no way he could have possibly committed this crime.”

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

“I don’t think he did it,” she said, crying.

wrongful-convictions: Trial by Fire

“I don’t think he did it,” she said, crying.

vimeo.com

Todd Willingham - Innocent Man Executed in Texas (Nightline Sept ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Todd Willingham - Innocent Man Executed in Texas (Nightline Sept ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Todd Willingham - Innocent Man Executed in Texas (Nightline Sept ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Todd Willingham - Innocent Man Executed in Texas (Nightline Sept ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Facebook

Watch World Premiere of Documentary about Todd Willingham "Death ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Todd Willingham - Innocent and Executed: Shout it from the ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Watch World Premiere of Documentary about Todd Willingham ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Johnny Webb (jailhouse informant)

A Gentleman's view. | Rick Perry's Texas Death Row!

Willingham is innocent of all charges.”

Texas Death Penalty: New Yorker Examines Texas' Execution of ...

Willingham is innocent of all charges.”

Texas Moratorium Network: New Yorker Examines Texas' Execution ...

Willingham is innocent of all charges.”

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

In March, 2000, several months after Gilbert’s visit, Webb unexpectedly sent Jackson a Motion to Recant Testimony, declaring, “Mr.

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

Willingham is innocent of all charges.”

the charles smith blog: CAMERON TODD WILLINGHAM CASE; DAVID GRANN ...

Willingham is innocent of all charges.”

wrongful-convictions: Trial by Fire

Willingham is innocent of all charges.”

Lethal Injection: Trial by Fire

Willingham is innocent of all charges.”

youtube.com

Todd Willingham - Innocent and Executed (Nightline Sept 17, 2009 ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Todd Willingham - Innocent and Executed (Nightline Sept 17, 2009 ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Todd Willingham - Innocent and Executed (Nightline Sept 17, 2009 ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Todd Willingham - Innocent and Executed (Nightline Sept 17, 2009 ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

Todd Willingham - Innocent and Executed (Nightline Sept 17, 2009 ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Todd Willingham - Innocent and Executed (Nightline Sept 17, 2009 ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

colonel6.com

President??? Texas Governor Rick Perry KILLED Cameron Todd ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

President??? Texas Governor Rick Perry KILLED Cameron Todd ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

11 | August | 2011 | Colonel6's Blog

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

11 | August | 2011 | Colonel6's Blog

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

11 | August | 2011 | Colonel6's Blog

Texas executed an innocent person.

President??? Texas Governor Rick Perry KILLED Cameron Todd ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

President??? Texas Governor Rick Perry KILLED Cameron Todd ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

11 | August | 2011 | Colonel6's Blog

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

topdog08.com

TOPDOG08.COM: September 2009 Archives

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

smithforensic.blogspot.com

the charles smith blog: CAMERON TODD WILLINGHAM CASE: BARRY SCHECK ...

After reading Grann's report, fair-minded people will know beyond a reasonable doubt that an innocent person was executed

texasdeathpenalty.org

Texas Death Penalty Education and Resource Center - Host Watch ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

burntorangereport.com

Todd Willingham's Defense Lawyer Embarrasses Texas Justice System ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Todd Willingham's Mother Responds to Rick Perry; Dr Craig Beyler ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Todd Willingham's Defense Lawyer Embarrasses Texas Justice System ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Todd Willingham's Defense Lawyer Embarrasses Texas Justice System ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Todd Willingham's Mother Responds to Rick Perry; Dr Craig Beyler ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Todd Willingham's Mother Responds to Rick Perry; Dr Craig Beyler ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Burnt Orange Report: Is Rick Perry Hiding Smoking Gun Information ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Burnt Orange Report: Is Rick Perry Hiding Smoking Gun Information ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Burnt Orange Report: Is Rick Perry Hiding Smoking Gun Information ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

change.org

Petition: Shout it From the Rooftops "Todd Willingham was Innocent ...

Now, we know for certain that he was telling the truth.

Petition: Shout it From the Rooftops "Todd Willingham was Innocent ...

Texas executed an innocent person.

Petition: Shout it From the Rooftops "Todd Willingham was Innocent ...

In fact, there was no arson, so there was no crime.

Petition: Shout it From the Rooftops "Todd Willingham was Innocent ...

He was innocent and Texas killed him.

agentlemansview.com

A Gentleman's view. | Rick Perry's Texas Death Row!

“I don’t think he did it,” she said, crying.

federalcriminaldefenseinvestigator.blogspot.com

Federal Criminal Defense Investigation: September 2009

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

calitics.com

Calitics:: It's Time to End the Death Penalty in California

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the "execution of a legally and factually innocent person."

tenthltr2u.wordpress.com

Cameron Todd Willingham Execution: Rick Perry's Role Deserves ...

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

hikergirl.tumblr.com

Life begins at 40 • Do you remember Cameron Todd Willingham?

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

hoyatalk2.proboards.com

HoyaTalk - 2012 Presidential Election Thread......

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the execution of a legally and factually innocent person.

3rdave.blogspot.com

The Third Avenue

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

brainsandeggs.blogspot.com

Brains and Eggs: Governor Perry's sociopathy

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

blogontherun.wordpress.com

Irredeemable; or, “What's the recourse if you make a mistake ...

There is a chance, however, that Texas could become the first state to acknowledge officially that, since the advent of the modern judicial system, it had carried out the “execution of a legally and factually innocent person.”

sheldensays.com

Innocent but executed

After reading Grann's report, fair-minded people will know beyond a reasonable doubt that an innocent person was executed

Guilty

Manuel Vasquez (arson analyst)

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

“Yes, sir,” Vasquez said.

Stacy Willingham (wife of Cameron Willingham)

wrongful-convictions: Trial by Fire

Unaware of Hurst’s report, she had determined that Willingham was guilty.

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

Unaware of Hurst’s report, she had determined that Willingham was guilty.

Cameron Todd Willingham's Real Last Words

Unaware of Hurst's report, she had determined that Willingham was guilty.

HorsesAss.Org » Blog Archive » GOP Debate Thread

Unaware of Hurst’s report, she had determined that Willingham was guilty.

Cameron Todd Willingham, Texas, and the death penalty : The New Yorker

Unaware of Hurst’s report, she had determined that Willingham was guilty.

the charles smith blog: August 2009

Unaware of Hurst’s report, she had determined that Willingham was guilty.

Lethal Injection: Trial by Fire

Unaware of Hurst’s report, she had determined that Willingham was guilty.

An Exploration of the relationship of Church and State

Unaware of Hurst’s report, she had determined that Willingham was guilty.

Windermere Roadies • View topic - Trial by Fire - Wrongly ...

Unaware of Hurst’s report, she had determined that Willingham was guilty.