Skeptive

  • Sources
    • Browse Sources
  • Disputes
    • Browse Disputes
    • Hottest Disputes
    • Newest Disputes
    • Incomplete Disputes
    • Add a New Dispute
  • Login/Join
  • View Dispute
  • Add Support
  • History
  • Tweet
  • Is this dispute interesting? Yes No

User Poll

Would the Japanese have surrendered without the use of nuclear bombs at Hiroshima and Nagasaki?

Summary

  • Posted: skeptive on Oct 28, 2010
  • Last Activity: amelie on Jan 21, 2012
  • Views: 13 times

Would the Japanese have surrendered without the use of nuclear bombs at Hiroshima and Nagasaki?

  • Yes

    PREDICTED RATING
    • 4
    • clear
    • clear
    • clear
    • clear
    • clear

    world-war-2.info (1 statement)

    World War 2

    Others contend that Japan had been trying to surrender for at least two months, but the US refused by insisting on an unconditional surrender�which they did not get even after the bombing, the bone of contention being retention of the Emperor.

    View source report for world-war-2.info

     

  • No

    PREDICTED RATING
    • 4
    • clear
    • clear
    • clear
    • clear
    • clear

    world-war-2.info (1 statement)

    World War 2

    In reply, defenders of the decision to use the bombs say that it is almost certain that the Japanese would not have surrendered without their use, and that hundreds of thousands - perhaps millions - would have perished in the planned U.S. invasion of Japan.

    View source report for world-war-2.info

     

Yes

world-war-2.info

World War 2

Others contend that Japan had been trying to surrender for at least two months, but the US refused by insisting on an unconditional surrender�which they did not get even after the bombing, the bone of contention being retention of the Emperor.

No

world-war-2.info

World War 2

In reply, defenders of the decision to use the bombs say that it is almost certain that the Japanese would not have surrendered without their use, and that hundreds of thousands - perhaps millions - would have perished in the planned U.S. invasion of Japan.

  • Get the Skeptive Toolbar
  • About Skeptive
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Contact

© 2012 Skeptive. Visit us on Facebook