November 29, 2012
| 09:29 |
rourbill
|
Changed dispute from “Is everyone who is born on American soil a "natural born citizen" regardless of his parentage?” to “Is everyone who is born in the United States a "natural born citizen" regardless of his parentage?” |
|
| 09:28 |
rourbill
|
Changed dispute from “Was President Chester A. Arthur a natural born citizen of the United States?” to “Was President Chester Arthur a natural born citizen of the United States?” |
|
| 09:28 |
rourbill
|
Changed dispute from “True or False? "Chester Arthur's father was not a U.S. citizen at the time of Chester Arthur's birth."” to “True or False? "President Chester Arthur's father was not a U.S. citizen at the time of Chester Arthur's birth."” |
|
| 09:27 |
rourbill
|
Changed dispute from “True or False? "Hence, Chester Arthur was born to a father who was not a U.S. citizen at the time of his birth."” to “True or False? "Chester Arthur's father was not a U.S. citizen at the time of Chester Arthur's birth."” |
|
| 09:26 |
rourbill
|
Changed dispute from “True or False? "One thing is for sure: Bobby Jindal might possibly make a good president -- Marco Rubio would make a great president."” to “True or False? "Marco Rubio would make a great president."” |
|
| 09:25 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “It is unclear.”I suppose the argument becomes the legal definition of "natural born citizen", which is not clear and there are those who will argue all sides of the question.
Source: righttruth.typepad.com |
|
| 09:25 |
rourbill
|
Added Viewpoint : “It is unclear.” to Is Bobby Jindal a natural born citizen of the United States? |
|
| 09:25 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “True”One thing is for sure: Bobby Jindal might possibly make a good president -- Marco Rubio would make a great president.
Source: righttruth.typepad.com |
|
| 09:25 |
rourbill
|
Added dispute: True or False? "Marco Rubio would make a great president." |
|
| 09:25 |
rourbill
|
Added Viewpoint : “True” to True or False? "Marco Rubio would make a great president." |
|
| 09:25 |
rourbill
|
Added Viewpoint : “False” to True or False? "Marco Rubio would make a great president." |
|
| 09:25 |
rourbill
|
Added Page To Source: Right Truth: Marco Rubio and Bobby Jindal Not Eligible To Be President? |
|
| 09:23 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “Yes”Bobby Jindal IS a natural-born citizen.
Source: twitter.com |
|
| 09:23 |
rourbill
|
Completed dispute |
|
| 09:23 |
rourbill
|
Added Page To Source: Twitter / jstrevino: Bobby Jindal IS a natural-born ... |
|
| 09:09 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “Vermont”This causes a minor scandal easily thwarted by Chester, because Chester was born in Vermont…but at the same time, the fake scandal provides cover for the real scandal.
Source: naturalborncitizen.wordpress.com |
|
| 09:08 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “Vermont”It was very convenient for Arthur that Hinman kept the focus on the extraordinary and false claim – that Arthur was born abroad – while the more subtle and true eligibility issue stayed hidden in plain site.
Source: naturalborncitizen.wordpress.com |
|
| 09:06 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “Vermont”It’s been definitively established that Chester Arthur was born in Vermont.
Source: naturalborncitizen.wordpress.com |
|
| 09:05 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “No”He wasn’t a “natural born citizen” and he knew it.
Source: naturalborncitizen.wordpress.com |
|
| 09:03 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “Vermont”Arthur biographer Thomas C. Reeves, a former University of Wisconsin history professor who wrote “Gentleman Boss’’ in 1975, debunked the born-in-Canada assertion.
Source: boston.com |
|
| 09:01 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “Canada”Hinman traveled to Vermont and Canada to research Arthur’s past, eventually concluding that Arthur was born in Canada but appropriated the birth records of a baby brother who was born in Fairfield, but died as an infant.
Source: boston.com |
|
| 09:01 |
rourbill
|
Added Page To Source: Chester Arthur rumor still lingers in Vermont - The Boston Globe |
|
| 08:59 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “It is unclear.”Unlike President Obama, who is clearly eligible to hold the nation’s highest office, Arthur, the twenty-first president (1881-84), may well have been an “unconstitutional” president.
Source: law.marquette.edu |
|
| 08:59 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “It is unclear.”We will probably never know if Arthur was really eligible to be president of the United States in 1881.
Source: law.marquette.edu |
|
| 08:57 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “Vermont”Arthur himself always insisted that he was born in Vermont, but he may not have known the place of his birth.
Source: law.marquette.edu |
|
| 08:56 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “Ireland”Hinman initially undermined his owned credibility by embracing an argument that Arthur was himself born in Ireland and didn’t come to the United States until he was fourteen years old.
Source: law.marquette.edu |
|
| 08:56 |
rourbill
|
Added Viewpoint : “Ireland” to Where was President Chester A. Arthur born? |
|
| 08:55 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “Yes”If this was true, then he was clearly a natural born citizen.
Source: law.marquette.edu |
|
| 08:55 |
rourbill
|
Added Statement To Viewpoint: “Canada”On the other hand, the competing account has it that he was born during his pregnant mother’s visit to her family’s home in Canada.
Source: law.marquette.edu |
|
| 08:55 |
rourbill
|
Completed dispute |
|